One of the biggest challenges in my acquiring English academic writing was when I took a major course titled Research Practice in Academic Writing and English Language Learners. That was my second semester in the US. Writing a critical review of a research article for that course was practically my first time to write an academic paper at a graduate school in the US. I guess my challenges were two-fold: on the one hand, I was not familiar with what an academic paper is supposed to be like, and on the other hand, I felt that my command of English was not strong enough to reveal my voice. Not surprisingly, I got a bad grade on that critical review with brutal comments that actually hurt my feelings.
But at the end of the semester, I became confident about writing and enjoyed the delights of accomplishments because those brutal comments were the start of my learning, although I realized that after I finished the class. What turned hurting-emotions feedback into a constructive learning advice was the professor’s continued dedication throughout the semester. In the beginning I revised my drafts multiple times because I appreciated the teacher’s time and energy that she put into my work. I knew that it was pretty hard for her to give the sheer amount of feedback to each of the multiple drafts for one paper. Whenever I revised my draft, she allowed me to send it to her via email and sent each draft with her written feedback. Thanks to her, I was able to get a sense of how logical can be considered ‘logical,’ how developed can be counted as ‘fully developed,’ when I need citation, and how I can support my ideas and so on.
Working a piece of paper in a multiple-draft setting like that was a process of learning of what an academic paper is like in a given discourse community. Through a series of getting feedback and responding to them, I interacted with the teacher, who represented the academic discourse community. The more familiar I became, the more confident I felt when I voiced while writing.
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
What you described is a good example of process oriented writing instruction. I'd like to hear more about your views on that. Were you able to transfer the skills you gained from this experience in other types of writing tasks? How were you evaluated? Did you see improvement in your lexicon, semantics etc.?
ReplyDelete